It’s a blessed occasion for me to have received the opportunity of watching three masters of their form share their concrete vision with this cinephile, over the past few days as I took time out of my schedule to accommodate precious hours for these works.

That special feeling of being privy to the intensity and many hues of landmark cinema by SATYAJIT RAY and INGMAR BERGMAN enriched me and the medium of watching them (courtesy YouTube) didn’t make a sliver of difference. I believe in the moving image’s sanctity and hence the screen ratio isn’t even an afterthought. If you ask me then personally I feel that YouTube and other streaming services are committing a great deed by making these classic titles available to us. Ultimately, watching them is a personalized experience for everyone.

So without further ado, let me write about each of the four works by these international icons and reserve praise for another recent entry into Netflix’s gallery of successes with NEWS OF THE WORLD, helmed by another master filmmaker Paul Greengrass and pivoted towards its destination by the gravitational pull of Tom Hanks’ noble aura plus a scene stealing turn by breakout star HELENA ZENGEL. This Western should join the genre’s hall of fame.


TEEN KANYA( THREE WOMEN/ THREE GIRLS) is an anthology film by one of India’s finest filmmakers and Oscar winner Satyajit Ray, released in 1961. What makes the two films that I watched, among its trio of tales written originally by Nobel laureate Rabindranath Tagore, is that it keeps its local soul, the Bengali flavour alive. That’s the reason why the universality of his emotional output resonates even today and has particularly been preserved as an heirloom within not just national annals but around the world.

Taking cues from its period settings, the essence of human nature is illustrated as being the same between then and now. It’s his tender, delicate and evocative touch that give these stories a folkloric whiff yet a personal beat to lives portrayed without exhausting a single minute of the little details that matter.

In SAMAPTI( THE END), now legendary actor and filmmaker Aparna Sen beautifully writs large the innocence and carefree nature of teenage and the pain of expecting to grow up overnight as a bride. Her unbridled spirit, however, is at odds with convention and all she wants is to ride the swing by the river and tend to her pet squirrel.

It’s a gradual movement towards acknowledging the decency and patience of her husband (another legendary star Saumitra Chatterjee) who she once laughed at as he slipped in the mud and who clearly understands her unwillingness to suddenly transition into a better half because she’s too young to know intricacies of life itself. To me, the lead protagonist’s journey informs us of an era when the perils of early marriages and being designated as a teenage bride was very potent. Once again, the healthy camaraderie in the man-woman bond is a hallmark, something Ray is adept at. Gita Dey and Sita Mukherjee too lend credence to the quicksilver bonds of maternal love and exasperation here.


MONIHARA( THE LOST JEWELS) is another part of this anthology; human greed for riches and the collateral damage wrought out of it is constructed ably by Mr. Ray in this instance. It’s essentially a ghost story, only the horror here is generated by a man’s ( Kali Banerjee) disbelief at his wife’s( Kanika Majumdar) betrayal and abandonment in a moment of financial crisis while her obsession with her box of jewels adds such layers of complexity to her already unpredictable exterior that it’s disconcerting to witness a bond of love and camaraderie surrender its effusion at the altar of material comforts.

Gobinda Chakravarti as the raconteur of this local legend strings the tale in a fashion we can identify as every aristocratic remnant boasts of such melancholy. Mr. Ray captures the mood of that isolation, that sense of dread and internalized pain for the male lead here in a haunting 53 minute capsule.

I will also recommend the celebrated series STORIES BY RABINDRANATH TAGORE, an original miniseries from Indian network Epic, currently streaming on Netflix too, to have a modern taste of these two tales especially, along with its entire ensemble. Period appropriate cinematography, mood, dialogues, excellently nuanced performances and social consciousness make it worthwhile and a worthy addition to the canon of works taking a leaf out of Tagore’s timeless ouevre.


Ingmar Bergman’s omnibus reaches its spiritually terrifying summit in HOUR OF THE WOLF (1968) whose central couple ( Liv Ullmann and Max Von Sydow) clash with their inner emptiness even as the spark of togetherness is palpable to their sustained bond of many years. Without making the why and whats of the situation, it’s the island imagery, otherwise serene and cut off from the hustle and bustle of city life, that slowly clears an inlet for human depravity as the introverted artist husband is beguiled by a group of sequestered aristocrats.

Their idiosyncrasies gradually warp him and the horror of his unique station in life becomes a living nightmare for him, fed by his past and impinging on the present. His dutiful wife is the point of view personage and is given contemplative passages of quiet strength offset by her better half’s stricken conscience.

Bergman and cinematographic collaborator Sven Nykvist provide it with a terrifying visual palette in sepia tones, the light and shadows evoking a chilling sense of dread, an internalized one at that. The screenplay hence has an ominous property, with unforgettable individual scenes, conversational exchanges simmering with unease and the lucid clarity of Liv Ullmann’s predicament and quest for a truth that goes beyond reason.

HOUR OF THE WOLF evokes Scandinavian legends and is attuned to realism. That’s why it is so effective and memorably haunting, akin to a nightmare scenario brought by class relations and artistic ennui.


THE SILENCE (1963) is an apt title for this bleak study of human relationships, a cinematic examination of filial distance that is painfully realistic. With its emphasis on naturalistic sound, especially clocks, and a lead character suffering from an undisclosed physical condition leading to excruciating pain, it was reminiscent of CRIES AND WHISPERS (1972) to this writer. As it’s a story cueing sibling dynamics, it becomes its companion piece though THE SILENCE was released a decade ago.

The more I think about it, the more I am intrigued by its no holds barred look at the way years of prior tensions implode with simmering rage and claustrophobic tempers for two siblings (played excellently by GUNNEL LINDBLOM and INGRID THULIN) who expose depths of control, regret and indifference in showcases of collective individuality. Sensuality very tastefully aids their reckoning. A breakdown of the spirit concludes it on an ambiguous note of even more pain and no closure.

At the end of the day, the child’s (JORGEN LINDSTROM) guileless innocence oversees a pantomime of silent reckoning in a foreign land with a foreign tongue, when he meets a group of liliputs and the elderly waiter at the hotel who all seem to speak a garbled tongue, almost like silent cinema. This puts it firmly in place with the central theme of lack of communication among adults.

Anyway, I feel very few filmmakers can represent the many layers of repression with such exactitude like Bergman. These two titles attest to that.




A western, by its structure, is meant to be modeled a certain way. There will be a conflict of interest pitting one’s self-preservation against greater forces of man, nature and the frontier of life. All this will predate modern American society and be a reflection of the cross-currents that shaped it. Harsh living conditions co-existing with survival instincts will guide relationships. Evil in the form of parochial, patriarchal modus operandi will approach from all sides and eventually be vanquished.

NEWS OF THE WORLD ticks those boxes but in its paternal core of warmth and selflessness finds Tom Hanks matching his sense of humility with that of an orphan girl who is every bit his equal in terms of screen time and emotional parallelism. Helena Zengel is a great discovery and by dint of her linguistic adaptability broadens her breadth of storytelling focus.

I was also impressed by the parts enacted by the formidable likes of MARE WINNINGHAM, ELIZABETH MARVEL, MICHAEL COVINO and BILL CAMP.

NEWS OF THE WORLD is a true Western, aided by its cinematography, music and the essence of life then. It must be watched by all.


3 thoughts on “THE MASTERS AT WORK

  1. I’m so glad, PC, that you carved out some time to catch up on the films you reviewed. Clearly, they channeled and challenged your inner landscape of emotions and deep love of film. I’m intrigued to watch the Indian films you mentioned, especially on the heels of recently seeing LIKE STARS ON EARTH, which I’m sure you realize had a HUGE impact on me as I wrote in my film review. You’ll always get me talking incessantly when it comes to Ingmar Bergman, as I’m sure you know. I have to admit, though, that I have not seen HOUR OF THE WOLF all the way, which is a downright shame for someone like me who considers Bergman the greatest film director who ever lived and probably the greatest director who will ever be when the final curtain comes down on all of us (probably sooner than later if I’m paying attention to the world, which I prefer not to pay attention to AT ALL). Makes me wonder why I never made it all the way through HOUR OF THE WOLF? I think you hit the nail on the head in your review when you wrote, the “introverted artist” and his nightmare unfolding which describes me to a “T” (as in “Timothy”). Maybe I haven’t watched the film all the way through because I fear the pain of my own nightmare unfolding in due time as an “introverted artist.” Boy, I’m not looking forward to that AT ALL! THE SILENCE as I’m sure you are aware of is the last film of Bergman’s God’s Silence Trilogy (the other two, THROUGH A GLASS DARKLY and WINTERLIGHT). I have to admit that when I first saw THE SILENCE, I thought it was a pale comparison to these other two Bergman masterpieces of filmmaking. But now, after having seen THE SILENCE multiple times, I line it up perfectly and accordingly with the previous two. No other film director can possibly “touch” what Bergman “touches,” which is the whole notion that we as humans fail miserably to communicate with one another and we fail miserably to understand that this “silence of God” that we claim to “hear” is because we are talking WAY TOO MUCH so as to leave God asking, “Can you please shut up so I can actually talk to you?” This reminds me of the Bible verse, “Therefore, my beloved brethren, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath” (James 1:19). If we would just shut up for two minutes and stop all that “mind mess,” we might be able to hear what God is saying to us. But because we have “mind mess” because the world is completely A MESS, we fail to hear swiftly because we are talking too swiftly. We fail to slow our speech because we just feel so intent on speaking profusely. Not only can God not get a word in edgewise but also those in our midst are just waiting for us to shut up. Maybe they are waiting for us to shut up so they can speak. Once again, Bergman in THE SILENCE gets all this, and it might have to do with his own father being a Lutheran minister that he gets this, i.e., his own father probably didn’t know when to shut up either, thus not listening to our little friend, Ingmar, who wanted to be heard. Thank God Ingmar got that “magic lantern” so he could write and direct a much-needed light on all our lives, particularly those who were not listened to in our youth, those of us who went unnoticed, unloved, and unappreciated. Yes, that, too, would describe me to a “T” (as in “Timothy). Your review of NEWS OF THE WORLD, which I have not seen, made me think of Malick’s DAYS OF HEAVEN, which was such an incredibly beautiful (well-deserved Oscar winner for Best Cinematography) film, all the more brilliant by the young girl’s narration in that film. Without her, the film would have been a disappointment, and it sounds like the presence of the young girl in NEWS OF THE WORLD was needed to keep that film from being a disappointment. I am not a fan of Tom Hanks at all, but it sounds like he was brilliant, as well. Western films just “ain’t my thing” unless they are poetically realized, and it sounds like NEWS OF THE WORLD might be just that and thus might be just “my thing.” 😉

    Thanks again for your wonderful writing, PC!



    1. Thank you for always suffusing my world with your heartiest appreciation.

      Yes, I know that THE SILENCE is part of a trilogy and WINTERLIGHT has already been added to my list and will be watched my me this week.

      Thank you for your eloquence, simplicity and egoless appreciation of another.


      1. Thanks, PC. Don’t let the apparent “simplicity” of WINTER LIGHT fool you. It’s one of the “deepest” films I’ve ever seen!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s